Frankston City Heritage Study

Stokesay

288-289 Nepean Highway, Seaford

Stokesay

Study Grade: A
Type: House
Construction Date: 1921
First Owner: Onians, Arthur and Amy
Architect: Ballantyne, Frederick
FCC Property Number: 21/0010/44304
Historic Buildings Register: Registered
National Trust of Australia (Class/Rec.): Classified
NTA File Number: 6015

History
Built: 1922
Architect J.F.W. (Frederick) Ballantyne designed Stokesay in March, 1922 for Arthur & Amy Onians.1 Originally designed as the Onians' seaside home, Stokesay soon became their permanent residence. It is probably that the house was built by Ballantyne as the general contractor.2

The property overlooks the bay and backs onto Kananook Creek. Stokesay once had a private jetty which jutted out into Kananook Creek.3 A garage and laundry were situated adjacent to the house and a large fowl house occupies part of the property.4 In 1925 Stokesay was awarded the First Prize in the Australian Home Beautiful competition for 'Australia's prettiest home'. Stokesay has remained unaltered an in the Onians family since its construction.5

Frederick Ballantyne entered the University of Melbourne in 1918. It was still necessary at that time to be articled to a practising architect.6 Ballantyne, on the advice of Edward Billson who worked in Griffin's office, became a pupil of Walter Burly Griffin. Ballantyne, at the age of 21 years, received his diploma ad completed his articles in 1921.7 In 1922, when he designed Stokesay, Ballantyne set up in private practice with an office at 313 Glenferrie Road, Malvern. In 1923 he travel to the United States, where he met Louis Sullivan and Dwight perkins and visited many buildings designed by Frank Lloyd Wright.8 Returning in 1924 he set up office in Haverbrack Avenue, Malvern. He and his brother, Keith, who had worked for a shot time with Griffin, carried on the family contracting business and many of the houses designed by Ballantyne at this time were also built by him.9 In 1934 Ballantyne went into partnership with one of his senior employees and cousin, Roy Wilson, a partnership which became known as Ballantyne and Wilson.10

Description
This complex is thought to be one of the best and the most complex examples of Walter Burley Griffin's Knitlock Wall construction system. Possessing the distinctive pyramid-shaped roof of Griffin's Knitlock prototype Pholiota, the house modules are roofed with the Marseilles pattern cement tile, rather than Griffin's Knitlock cement tile, seen on the Jefferies Surrey Hills house. Inside the pyramid form is reflected in the (Large) living room ceiling profile, like Chancellor and Patrick's pitched ceilings of the 1950s. As with the smaller Knitlock prototypes, such as the 1922 Gumnuts (q.v.), this living area, with its large fireplace, was used as the circulation space to the perimeter rooms, some with double (glazed) doors (sleepouts), and the dining room with none. Dressing rooms were provided to the sleepouts and a 'workroom' to the main bedroom. typical of the era, there was plenty of built-in storage and, less typical, a maid's room. The garage and the laundry were housed in another pyramid-roof building on the site, north of the house, while the perimeter hedges, garden pathways and fencing provided a notable setting for the two buildings.

The house had a jetty onto the Kananook Creek and a croquet lawn.

External Integrity
Generally original except for only slight possibility that the roof tiles were once knitlock

Context
The landscape (hedges) provides a buffer for this complex from the highway. It is identifiable as one of a diminishing number of between-the-wars houses established in this part of the Point Nepean Road prior to the onset of higher density development via flats and unity, post-War.

Landscape
The layout is intact, together with structures such as the entrance gates, timber garage, gravel paths, a series of tall clipped cypress arches (Cupressus sempervirens?), orchard and rear sheds.

Significance – Study Grading A
Architecturally, this house complex perhaps the best preserved Knitlock example in Australia and one of the few to incorporate suburban elements such as garages into the system; also designed by one of Griffin's first articled pupils, Frederick Ballantyne, in a form which was faithfull to the internationally known architect, Walter Burley Griffin's original Pholiota concept, by providing on central space as the focus for ancillary rooms/alcoves around the perimeter: of national importance.

Historically, acknowledged by a national periodical as 'Australia's Prettiest House', it represents a nationally publicised ideal in a time of housing shortages and many attempts to develop cheap construction systems. Historically, it is of added significance in that it has been lived in by the one family since its construction also as still the home of Mrs. Gladys Hartley Watson, well-known in the Girl Guide and charity movements: of National interest and State importance.

The landscape is of regional importance.


NOTES
1 NTA FN6015
2 ibid.
3 ibid.
4 ibid.
5 ibid.
6 ibid.
7 ibid.
8 ibid.
9 ibid.
10 see P. Goad, P. Navaretti, NTA classification (1988) report